Hi, I’m James, a Foot and Ankle Specialist. Today, I’ll guide you through the Brooks Cascadia 18 and the Hoka Speedgoat 6, two popular trail running shoes. While both are excellent options, they serve distinct purposes. In this post, we’ll dive into their differences in cushioning, fit, performance, and how their design can impact certain medical conditions
Cushioning: Comparing Stack Heights and Drop
The Brooks Cascadia 18 features a stack height of 33mm in the rearfoot and 25mm in the forefoot, providing an 8mm drop. This design suits runners seeking balanced cushioning for versatile terrain, including road-to-trail transitions.
In contrast, the Hoka Speedgoat 6 is a max-cushion shoe with 40mm in the rearfoot and 35mm in the forefoot, offering a 5mm drop. This low-drop design promotes even pressure distribution across the foot, which can benefit runners with conditions like metatarsalgia or Morton’s neuroma.
Cushioning Technology
- Cascadia 18: Equipped with a rock plate for added underfoot protection and stability, the Cascadia provides a springy, balanced ride.
- Speedgoat 6: Utilizes CMEVA foam for responsive cushioning and energy return, offering a plush yet stable experience.
Buy Shoes on Amazon
Fit: Toe Box, Tongue, and Heel Counter
Toe Box
- Cascadia 18: Offers a slightly roomier toe box, ideal for runners with wider feet or conditions like bunions.
- Speedgoat 6: Tends to taper more, which can feel snug, especially downhill. This may not be ideal for runners with Morton’s neuroma or bunion pain.
Tongue and Heel Counter
- Cascadia 18: Features a padded gusseted tongue and moderate heel counter stability for a secure fit.
- Speedgoat 6: Has a thin gusseted tongue, which may cause discomfort for runners with sensitive ankles. The heel counter provides mild stability, prioritizing lightweight comfort.
Performance: Outsole Grip and Trail Suitability
Outsole Design
- Speedgoat 6: Built for technical trails, it boasts a Vibram Megagrip outsole with 5mm multidirectional lugs for excellent traction on wet, muddy, and rocky terrain.
- Cascadia 18: Uses TrailTack Green Rubber, made with 25% recycled material, and 4.5mm lugs for reliable grip on moderate trails.
Versatility
- Speedgoat 6: Excels as a road-to-trail shoe but isn’t ideal for extended road running due to outsole wear.
- Cascadia 18: Designed as a trail-specific shoe, it’s comfortable on technical runs and longer trail adventures
Medical Considerations: How Profiles Impact Foot Health
- Metatarsalgia and Morton’s Neuroma: The Speedgoat 6‘s low drop and cushioning help evenly distribute pressure, reducing forefoot pain.
- Bunions: The Cascadia 18’s wider fit provides relief by minimizing pressure on the toe box.
- Achilles Tendon Issues: The Cascadia 18‘s higher drop can alleviate tension on the Achilles, making it a better choice for those with tendon discomfort.
Weight and Durability
- Speedgoat 6: Lightweight at 277g (men’s US 9), ideal for long distances.
- Cascadia 18: Slightly heavier at 314g (men’s US 9), offering more stability and durability.
Buy Shoes on Amazon
Final Thoughts
Both the Brooks Cascadia 18 and the Hoka Speedgoat 6 are exceptional trail running shoes, but their differences make them suited for specific needs:
- Choose the Cascadia 18 for stability, versatility, and technical trail runs.
- Opt for the Speedgoat 6 if you need a lightweight, max-cushion shoe for long-distance or technical terrain.
